I guess it's important to realize the reason behind the painting in the first place. I bought a Superman outfit as a gift to my nephew Max, for his 2nd birthday. Seeing the pictures of him wearing the costume got me thinking of his next birthday gift, but the clincher was that Max saw the painting that I did for his sister Sadie and actually asked where was his painting from me. So, I had no choice at this point. I was helpless against his strong-armed tactics.
However it was important to me that this picture was not simply kitch. I wanted this painting to be a piece of art that he could grow up with to remind him not to forget his childhood dreams, his innocence, and hope for the future. Or his cool Uncle Terry, of course!
Reference
I shot a lot of photos of Max the next time we got together for the holidays. Luckily, his dad was very helpful in coercing Max into the Superman positions. However, even with all of photos, I was not happy with just one, so I was forced to use his head from one shot and pasted it onto his body of another. (Thank you photoshop.) Here is that photo:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/df5f1/df5f1c7bea38e62d31611149557251358b27ea57" alt=""
Original Painting
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ecab8/ecab86b6d6d33a8e2478bd4b69dbd2d3fa4b8e67" alt=""
1) I needed some digital samples for my portfolio.
2) I wanted to "prepaint" the idea to see if I'd be happy with it before committing to a real canvas.
3) I wouldn't be able to finish the real thing on canvas quick enough in time for his birthday.
While I was somewhat pleased with the result, I felt I could do better. The background was simply "too green" for my liking and the composition could be more dynamic. So I was determined to do better.
New Background Compositional Value Studies
So I regrouped, did more background research ideas to get inspired and did some rather quick background studies in photoshop. Since the figure was already done, I could paste it on top of the new studies and get a "feel" for what end result may be.
ONE:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/07d8e/07d8ea517053f843192046263e3c155e0c56dace" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b0941/b09414f5f4736eec5cff624c162681e68b97b83d" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3d305/3d305c1d0a6e1d33e5934ddb01031754ff8c4a11" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/028ab/028abb10f379ecf4236b64545fdaf55e363f8020" alt=""
Color Studies
So wanting this version to be better than the last, I took one extra step. I did some quick color studies, varying from realistic to just somewhat more pushed. As a matter of fact, the one that was chosen from my small peer "feedback" group, was the last one that I did simply on a lark. I didn't expect it to be chosen, but just wanted to fill out the choices some. It wasn't unanimous on this one, just a majority vote. So you just never know, you know?
Realistic Colors:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6da5d/6da5db92f0db37d8c470b18b960fbb88e4b1b2f0" alt=""
Color pushed towards cyan:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6ee50/6ee502fbc1a5e415304132c431cf7cb4f97cd560" alt=""
Colors pushed cooler with more atmosphere:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a7242/a72421a6701ac153878213bb66c58d9ffa36b73b" alt=""
To go from the color study to the final was actually not bad at all. Since I had most of the colors chosen already, I could just use the eyedropper tool in photoshop to make sure I was on color target. Honestly, it simply became a matter of cleaning up shapes, adding details, and dealing with edges. The final image:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e8945/e89458813513927eeaa19d6e12a396639f00c120" alt=""